Winning and Losing in 24 hours or Less

by bk

So pardon me for calling the election on September 2 but within the last day the first polls, showing Obama with 50%+, started showing up. I’ve long held that lots of America’s choose not to decide until after Labor Day. They can’t be bothered to, it’s just not in their blood like us partisan types. Every cycle just as the decidedly undecides starting tuning in to make their decision they use two events to judge the candidates – the convention acceptance speech and the Presidential candidate’s first executive decision on VP candidate. Some of the more serious undecides will watch and listen to everything, others will judge it by how others in and out of the media seems to perceive it. Depending on the year, the undecides may make the difference in a close election or simply pad the margin of victory. Ultimately, I believe turning out the base is the most important thing and by all measures the Democratic base is more enthusiastic this year than the Republican base so I’ve felt for awhile Obama would win and I’ve been looking to the undecides to provide the margin of victory. But that hasn’t been showing up in the polls yet so I’ve seen and heard a lot of hand wringing among Dems I know. It’s a natural reaction to how the last couple of elections have unfolded and I’m sure it will last until Obama takes the oath. But when the story of the 2008 Presidential Election is written, I believe the turning point will be fully encapsulated within less than 24 hours, the night of August 25th and the morning of August 26th.

More Americans tuned in for Barack Obama’s speech than tuned in for the Opening Ceremonies of the Olympics and the American Idol finales. He spoke to those who could be convinced, the 70%+ who believe we’re heading in the wrong direction. And they got a speech that knocked down the patriotism attacks while making the attackers look petty, they got policy proposals and soaring and flawless rhetoric, and they got to see a man they could believe could be President. The expectations were high and he still managed to surpass them; he passed the test.

The very next morning, the other shoe dropped. McCain had named Sarah Palin as his running mate and across America a collective, “WHO?” rang out. Over the course of the next 2 days, it became obvious that McCain’s team hadn’t done the most basic of vetting. The choice was instinctual and a political sop to the base. In another year, that might have been okay but not considering recent history like the rush to war and the move to privatize social security, and recalling Republican appointments like Michael Brown, Harriet Meirs, and Alberto Gonzales, it was all too familiar and in 1 fell swoop it undercut McCain’s main argument against Obama and re-inforced Obama’s main line of attack on McCain, that a McCain Presidency would be more of the same.

There are only really two parts to the VP decision as far as the voting public is concerned. Number 1 is the heartbeat question. Are we comfortable with this person being a heartbeat from the Presidency? And number 2 and more importantly, what the choice says about the Presidential candidate. Context is very important. Quayle was an obvious sop to the right as the right was starting to really flex its muscles. But he had been in Congress for 12 years and the Senate for the previous 6 and Bush was a sporty, healthy WASP. McCain is a 72 year who has twice battled skin cancer and Palin is the 2 year governor of Alaska with prior experience as mayor of a town of 7,000. Barack Obama’s choice of Sen. Joe Biden was a serious choice who could easily step in to the Presidency at a moment’s notice. Barack passed. Outside the 28 Percenters, those that absolutely can’t see past their partisan blinders and still support Bush, John McCain’s choice was clearly questionable and no one believes she’s ready to be a heartbeat from the Presidency. So on the first test of a President McCain, McCain failed and he failed the same as Bush, playing to the base and playing politics with the future of America.

On the night of Thursday August 25th, Senator Barack Obama showed America a vision of its future. On the morning of Friday August 26th, Senator John McCain showed America a vision of its past, the past 8 years. Within that short time, John McCain lost the election and Barack Obama won it.

At least, that’s how I believe it will be remembered.


4 comments so far

  1. Cuz on

    Well said, cousin. I hope you are right. And I’ve certainly come to trust your opinion. (Especially in fantasy football 😉

  2. po on

    I agree that the 24 hour period you identify is, at least for now, the pivotal moment of the race. And I do so very much hope that your prediction proves correct. I dare say, the choice facing the myriad of supposedly “undecideds” seems clear and unquestionable to me. But that said, unbelievably there are still undecideds out there, so I feel the need to caution:

    Do not to count chickens before they hatch.

    The GOP are best when not talking about issues. McCain’s manager stated, only yesterday, that to them the campaign is, in fact, not about issues. Good move on their part, because his views on the issues likely won’t get him very far.

    If not issues, then what? What would the GOP like to make this campaign about?

    Ah, yes, feel good themes of a by-gone era that never existed, wrapped in: Lies. Doublespeak. Distortions. Obfuscation. In short, fairytales for those that don’t like to think much anyway.

    It worked enough against Gore (at least enough to steal the election). It worked against Kerry (but IMHO Kerry was a pathetic choice in the first place). While I certainly hope that America has learned its lesson after witnessing what GOP rule really is all about, we must realize that there’s a reason America does rank in the top of the international education chart these days.

    We must also remember that even though 70 % of America claims to not like where the country is heading. and Congress’ approaval rating is lower than W’s, the majority of Americans still believe their respective representatives are doing fine jobs.

    So while McCain is McSame, and Palin likely only a nutcase acceptable to the GOP “base”, they haven’t lost yet. And Bush won, twice, by playing to that base.

  3. JaminAtl on

    Pretty much the response I expected, po.

    Definitely understand about counting chickens but writing this piece on November 3 isn’t really putting myself out there. Besides I’m not the hand wringing type. I’ll leave that for you while I’m climbing out on a limb

    2008 is not 2000. In 2000, the 28 Percenters were at 35% so the base is not enough for them in 2008. Meanwhile, the Democratic base has grown stronger and is more enthusiastic.

    McCain is not Bush. I’m certainly afraid McCain’s governing style will be the same or worse, but he’s not the twofer Bush was, he’s not a born again, blue blood.

    Obama is not Gore. Gore represented a continuation of prosperous but turbulent time. Instead of embracing the positives from continuation, he ran from it all and ended up stuck with just the negatives. Barack is offering change when the overwhelming feeling is that is what we need. Plus Barack is smart AND charismatic.

    And Congress has always had low approval ratings so I don’t put to much stock in that.

    McCain’s campaign will do exactly what you say and selecting Palin was very much a part of that and what I’m saying is that it’s not gonna work this time and the Palin decision impact is the first tangible sign of that.

  4. JaminAtl on

    Interesting bit from TPM that speaks to our different points of view:

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: